ECON Committee consideration of draft report on CRAs

29 February 2012

The EU's credit rating agency reform plans need to be beefed up, in order to replace "unsolicited" sovereign debt ratings of EU Member States with ratings by an independent body, reduce reliance on agency ratings, and eliminate conflicts of interest that could influence them, said rapporteur Leonardo Domenici (S&D, IT).

"I believe that we should add something to the Commission proposal. It is a complex piece of work to explore some aspects and hold on to the details to avoid unexpected and unwanted effects", said Parliament's rapporteur on the reform plans, Leonardo Domenici (S&D, IT).

He also stressed: "We have to come up with new answers to the sovereign debt problem".

Prohibiting "unsolicited" sovereign debt ratings

Mr Domenici suggested prohibiting "unsolicited" sovereign debt ratings and instead setting up a fully-independent public European Credit Rating Agency to rate the creditworthiness of EU Member States. This idea, which goes well beyond the Commission's original proposal, drew a mixed response from MEPs in other political groups, who observed that trying to prohibit ratings was unrealistic. They had also varying views on the usefulness and credibility of the proposed European agency.

Ending over-reliance on ratings

Mr Domenici backed Commission efforts to end the over-reliance of private and public entities on external ratings, saying that financial market players should consider at least two independent ratings. To avoid "automatic" reactions to external ratings, internal rating capacities should be developed, he said.

Redefining ratings

The rapporteur also stressed the need to redefine ratings, so that they are treated as useful information, rather than as a "unilateral, unquestionable opinion" presented by an agency.

The draft report also recommends amending the Commission proposal in order to:

Next steps

The amendments will be considered in committee until 24 April. The Domenici report is to be put to a committee vote on 21 May

Press release


© European Parliament